Homestuck or not, this is a great cosplay. The outfit, the pose, the expression and the photograph are all beautiful! I don't like Homestuck that much, but I really like the cosplays, especially the great ones like these. Congrats on the DD!
It seems like there's three kinds of upset people and one kind of happy people here: 1. People who dislike homestuck. 2. People who like homestuck and realize this isn't necessarily 'DD-worthy'. 3. People who don't care about homestuck and realize this isn't necessarily 'DD-worthy'. and then 4. People who think homestuck stuff has never gotten a DD before (where have you been?)
That's just the vibe i'm getting. Overall I think this photo could have done a lot better, especially with the photoshop. Good job otherwise, tho.
why am i even analyzing anything it's almost eight in the morning
It's so wicked to see some Homestuck cosplay / photography in the daily deviations! And this is so well deserved. I am really very fond of this particular Karkat cosplay, and some other pictures that came out of the same shoot. Good work guys, you deserved this! [: